Pas une adaptation !

Avis sur Le Capital au XXIe siècle

Avatar Rei Ayanami
Critique publiée par le

AVERTISSEMENT Le titre est trompeur.
Il ne s'agit ni d'une adaptation du livre de Piketty ou du discours de celui-ci ni d'un documentaire à propos d'aujourd'hui ou de l'avenir. The intent here is probably to introduce people who had little knowledge about the system it alludes to to its workings and what led to the current situation. It is indeed little more than a brief history lesson.

That purpose is more or less fulfilled thanks to the rapid montage, use of alluring pop songs and snipets of Hollywood movies, leaving little room to the usual talking heads (including Piketty) we've come to expect from less formally ambitious documentaries, the lesser presence of graphs and the way it glances over many points (the more forgivable being the communism discarded in a few minutes by citing the fall of the USSR) or merely names some of them.
Thanks to those resulting shortcomings (or despite?), it constitutes an effective way for people uneducated with the subject to have a chance to get a basic understanding on it and maybe engage in further researches.

The conclusion is more in tunes with the title, since it acts as an overture to Piketty's thesis by giving him a few minutes to expose it. Who knows? It might lead a small part of the audience to open his book?

Score: 6/10 Sexy film for the 90s/2000s born curious who resisted their curiosity until now and can't watch an ARTE doc.
But will a theatrical release actually reach this population? (I think this film would better fit in Netflix)

Enjoyment: 3~4/5

Impression "personnelle":

When you don't learn anything to the point of rehassing over and over bad thoughts while watching a documentary whose themes were of interest to you, there's something wrong...
Also, for the same reasons it should catch the attention of the uninformed average people, it strongly annoyed me. I felt like the cuts from thing to thing were often random and the movies, however short they were, seemed disruptive. Idem for the few repeated songs.

La nature filmique nuit à l'aspect documentaire/informatif.
Score: 5/10 (ôtez 1 si vous êtes un minimum au courant de ces choses)
Plaisir: 1/5

Et vous, avez-vous apprécié la critique ?
Critique lue 332 fois
4 apprécient · 2 n'apprécient pas

Autres actions de Rei Ayanami Le Capital au XXIe siècle