S2 E1 • Nicktoons

January is Nickelodeon month, so the Nostalgia Critic decides to first take a look back at the popular nicktoon shows. He takes a look back at Ren and Stimpy, Rugrats, Doug, Rocko's Modern Life, AAAHH!!! Real Monsters, and Hey Arnold.

Première diffusion : 6 janvier 2009

S2 E2 • A Look Back At Nickcoms

Continuing with his Nickelodeon month reviews, the Nostalgia Critic looks back at the sitcoms of Nickelodeon, or as he calls them, the Nickoms. He looks back at You Can't Do That on Television, Clarissa Explains it All, Hey Dude, Salute your Shorts, and The Adventures of Pete and Pete.

Première diffusion : 13 janvier 2009

S2 E3 • SNICK

In honor of Nickelodeon month, the Nostalgia Critic takes a look back at the shows from the SNICK lineup. Among the shows that he reviews are Roundhouse, Are You Afraid of the Dark?, All That, Prometheus and Bob, Action League Now!, and Kenan & Kel.

Première diffusion : 21 janvier 2009

S2 E4 • Good Burger

After failing to find footage for Nickelodeon game shows, the Nostalgia Critic instead reviews the Nickelodeon movie Good Burger. However, with many poor jokes and annoying characters, will reviewing this movie be worth it?

Première diffusion : 27 janvier 2009

S2 E5 • The Making of the Final Battle

This video shows behind-the-scenes footage and the making of the final battle between the Nostalgia Critic and The Angry Video Game Nerd.

Première diffusion : 30 janvier 2009

S2 E6 • Ferngully

The Nostalgia Critic and The Nostalgia Chick team up to review FernGully: The Last Rainforest. With uninspired characters, scientific inaccuracies, a preachy attitude, and pointless scenes, will this movie be too horrible for even two critics to handle?

Première diffusion : 3 février 2009

S2 E7 • A Kid in King Arthur's Court

The Nostalgia Critic reviews A Kid in King Arthur's Court. Although, with absurd situations, historical inaccuracies, and amateur filmmaking techniques, he finds that this movie turns out to be less entertaining than what it sounds like.

Première diffusion : 11 février 2009

S2 E8 • Good Son

The Nostalgia Critic reviews the movie Good Son. However, this movie is so bad that he lost his voice screaming at it and has to review it using cue cards.

Première diffusion : 13 février 2009

S2 E9 • Adventures of Sonic the Hedgehog

The Nostalgia Critic reviews two shows involving Sonic the Hedgehog, Adventures of Sonic the Hedgehog, as well as Sonic the Hedgehog. One will be utter trash and one will be brilliant by comparison. Which one is which?

Première diffusion : 18 février 2009

S2 E10 • Top 11 Nostalgic Mindfucks

Growing up, everyone has seen a show or movie that has had some kind of really twisted scene. So, the Nostalgia Critic decides to countdown the Top 11 most messed up moments.

Première diffusion : 24 février 2009

S2 E11 • Twister

The Nostalgia Critic reviews the movie Twister. With it's scientific inaccuracies and boring dialogue, he finds that this movie is the one doing all the sucking.

Première diffusion : 3 mars 2009

S2 E12 • Garbage Pail Kids

The Nostalgia Critic reviews The Garbage Pail Kids Movie. With disgusting characters, no plot, and exceptionally poor animatronics, the Nostalgia Critic finds that this movie is something else that belongs in a garbage pail.

Première diffusion : 11 mars 2009

S2 E13 • Rock A Doodle

The Nostalgia Critic reviews the movie Rock A Doodle. By pointing out its confusing narrative, the horrible acting of the young protagonist, and inconsistencies in the plot, he feels that this movie marks the decline of Don Bluth's career.

Première diffusion : 17 mars 2009

S2 E14 • Titanic: The Legend Goes On

The Nostalgia Critic takes on the movie Titanic: The Legend Goes On. However, with unrealistic relationships, bad editing, and a rapping dog, he feels that this movie should have went down with the ship.

Première diffusion : 24 mars 2009

S2 E15 • Pagemaster

The Nostalgia Critic reviews the movie Pagemaster. Although, with poorly developed characters and situations, will he get through the review without being bored to death?

Première diffusion : 13 mars 2009

S2 E16 • Neverending Story

As an April Fools Day special, Chester A. Bum reviews The Neverending Story in the Nostalgia Critic's place.

Première diffusion : 1 avril 2009

S2 E17 • Moonwalker

The Nostalgia Critic reviews the movie Moonwalker, but finds that it's just a big ego-trip for Michael Jackson. However, will one special musical number redeem the movie in his eyes?

Première diffusion : 8 avril 2009

S2 E18 • Top 11 Dumbest Superman Moments

The Superman movies are very nostalgic, but even they have had some dumb moments. So, the Nostalgia Critic counts down the Top 11 dumbest Superman moments.

Première diffusion : 15 avril 2009

S2 E19 • TMNT

Many users have requested that the Nostalgia Critic review the latest Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles movie. So, he decides to review TMNT. Will he find the movie to be just as good as the originals, or is it beyond his generation?

Première diffusion : 22 avril 2009

S2 E20 • Red Sonja

The Nostalgia Critic reviews the movie Red Sonja. However, with lackluster performances and Brigitte Nielsen and Arnold Schwarzenegger as the stars, will he find the movie interesting, or just boring and hard to understand?

Première diffusion : 5 mai 2009

S2 E21 • Short Circuit 1 and 2

The Nostalgia Critic reviews both Short Circuit and Short Circuit 2. With two movies starring a talking robot, how could it possibly be bad?

Première diffusion : 13 mai 2009

S2 E22 • Batman vs Dark Knight

The Nostalgia Critic introduces a new way to review and compare similar movies. This time he compares the original 1989 Batman to the 2008 Dark Knight movie. Which one will emerge as the better Batman movie?

Première diffusion : 20 mai 2009

S2 E23 • Full House

The Nostalgia Critic reviews the show Full House. Despite it being a popular television show, he can't understand how it lasted so long with bland characters and unfunny jokes.

Première diffusion : 26 mai 2009

S2 E24 • North

With the movie North being so widely known as being terrible, even by Siskel and Ebert, the Nostalgia Critic can't help but review it. With unfunny jokes and extremely stereotypical and racist ethnicities being portrayed, perhaps he should have passed this one up.

Première diffusion : 3 juin 2009

S2 E25 • Critic and Nerd: TMNT Making of Coming Out of Their Shells

Deciding to put aside their differences and review something together, the Nostalgia Critic and The Angry Video Game Nerd decide to review a documentary about a Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles band. However, this movie may be so bad that not even the two of them can handle it.

Première diffusion : 10 juin 2009

S2 E26 • Sidekicks

The Nostalgia Critic reviews the movie Sidekicks. With a kid constantly dreaming about Chuck Norris, the film becomes even more self-indulgent than Moonwalker. Can Chuck Norris save the movie from the wrath of the Nostalgia Critic?

Première diffusion : 17 juin 2009

S2 E27 • Gargoyles

The Nostalgia Critic salutes the Walt Disney show, Gargoyles.

Première diffusion : 24 juin 2009

S2 E28 • Transformers 2

In honor of his first review, the Nostalgia Critic goes back to his original formula for reviewing the latest Transformers movie, Transformers 2.

Première diffusion : 27 juin 2009

S2 E29 • Steel

The Nostalgia Critic reviews Steel. With Shaquille O'Neal's wooden acting when trying to portray a super hero, this movie is going to be easy for the Nostalgia Critic to bash.

Première diffusion : 1 juillet 2009

S2 E30 • Top 11 Cereal Mascots

If there is one thing that kids know best, it is cereal. So, the Nostalgia Critic counts down the Top 11 cereal mascots.

Première diffusion : 7 juillet 2009

S2 E31 • Barb Wire

The Nostalgia Critic reviews the movie Barb Wire, a movie that he thinks was made solely to show off Pamela Anderson's body.

Première diffusion : 14 juillet 2009

S2 E32 • LOTR Animated vs LOTR

The Nostalgia Critic compares the 1978 animated The Lord of the Rings movie and the Lord of the Rings trilogy. Which one will be considered the best Lord of the Rings movie?

Première diffusion : 22 juillet 2009

S2 E33 • Last Action Hero

The Nostalgia Critic reviews the movie Last Action Hero. With Arnold Schwarzenegger's accent and how the movie pokes fun at itself, the Nostalgia Critic finds it hard to comment on the movie. However, with so many random star appearances and lack of realism, he still gives it a try.

Première diffusion : 29 juillet 2009

S2 E34 • Captain N

The Nostalgia Critic reviews the show Captain N: The Game Master. Even though he likes Nintendo, it still doesn't make up for the show's undeveloped characters that barely resemble their video game designs, as well as the fact that it constantly plugs Nintendo characters and products.

Première diffusion : 4 août 2009

S2 E35 • We're Back!

The Nostalgia Critic decides to review We're Back: A Dinosaur's Story in the style of Hunter S. Thompson.

Première diffusion : 12 août 2009

S2 E36 • Warriors of Virtue

The Nostalgia Critic reviews the movie Warriors of Virtue. Despite the fact that it promises martial arts and kangaroos, he finds the movie to be incredibly boring.

Première diffusion : 18 août 2009

S2 E37 • Captain America

The Nostalgia Critic reviews the movie Captain America. However, he finds that this super hero is portrayed like a pushover and always getting beaten.

Première diffusion : 25 août 2009

S2 E38 • Top 11 F*ck Ups

Everyone makes mistakes, and the Nostalgia Critic is no exception. So, he counts down the Top 11 mistakes he's made so far.

Première diffusion : 1 septembre 2009

S2 E39 • Alone In The Dark

After being requested to review an Uwe Boll movie, the Nostalgia Critic decides to review Alone in The Dark. However, the movie is so bad that he loses his voice and is forced to use the Macintalk to speak. Just before he's ready to give up, Spoony and Linkara decide to help him review the movie. Will three critics be enough to review an Uwe Boll movie?

Première diffusion : 8 septembre 2009

S2 E40 • Blank Check

The Nostalgia Critic reviews the movie Blank Check, a movie that blandly ripoffs many ideas from other movies, especially Home Alone. He also finds that there is a weird romantic relationship involving a kid, Preston, and Shay, a full grown woman F.B.I. agent. With such a bland movie, the Nostalgia Critic finds it hard to enjoy it.

Première diffusion : 15 septembre 2009

S2 E41 • Halloween III

The Nostalgia Critic reviews the movie Halloween III. He finds that it is one of the strangest sequels that he has ever seen since it has nothing to do with the previous movies in the series. He also finds the movie to be very boring and not very scary.

Première diffusion : 17 septembre 2009

S2 E42 • Doug's Top 20 Favorite Movies (1)

After complaining about so many movies, Doug decides to reveal the top 20 movies that he likes the best. This is the first half of his countdown.

Première diffusion : 17 septembre 2009

S2 E43 • Doug's Top 20 Favorite Movies (2)

Continuing with the countdown of his top 20 favorite movies, Doug reveals the best of the best. This is his top 10 favorite movies of all time.

Première diffusion : 17 septembre 2009

S2 E44 • Willy Wonka vs. Charlie

The Nostalgia Critic compares the film Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory starring Gene Wilder to the 2005 remake, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory directed by Tim Burton and starring Johnny Depp. Which one will win?

Première diffusion : 22 septembre 2009

S2 E45 • Cool as Ice

The Nostalgia Critic reviews the film Cool as Ice, staring Vanilla Ice in his first and last acting role.

Première diffusion : 29 septembre 2009

S2 E46 • Suburban Commando

The Nostalgia Critic reviews the sci-fi comedy Suburban Commando, starring Hulk Hogan and talks about how some wrestlers just don't know how to act.

Première diffusion : 6 octobre 2009

S2 E47 • The Next Karate Kid

The Nostalgia Critic reviews The Next Karate Kid, a film that shows us that the Karate Kid movies have gotten pretty bad over the years.

Première diffusion : 13 octobre 2009

S2 E48 • Casper

The Nostalgia Critic reviews the 1995 live-action film, Casper. Will he like it, or will he find that the movie is so terrible that it's terrifying?

Première diffusion : 20 octobre 2009

S2 E49 • Superman IV

The Nostalgia Critic reviews the movie Superman IV: The Quest for Peace. With cheap effects and several plot holes, this movie may be too awful to be reviewed by just one reviewer.

Première diffusion : 27 octobre 2009

S2 E50 • Congo

The Nostalgia Critc reviews the movie Congo that teaches us the difference between real gorillas and guys in ape costumes.

Première diffusion : 3 novembre 2009