When i saw "Johnny got his gun", I already knew what to expect. It did not help much... When I saw "Grave of the Fireflies", I had no idea what i was about to see, et i'm aware now that it would not have helped anyway either...


I love this movie, just as much for the cruel simplicity of its theme (the impact of of a war on two kids), as for the fascinating poetry that it still carries. This poetry is not the by-product of easy cinematographic tricks , but a poetry much deeper in its foundations, the clear poetry of childhood.
As such, this work doesn't touch you so much through the scandal it denounces (so many movies have and will do this), as it does though the sheer accuracy of its children portraiture. Little Setsuko is infinitely moving because her authenticity bursts through the screen. The movie is peppered of these little childhood moments, hands that hold each other, incontrolable fits of laughter, hugs, all these little gestures that stem from the immense desire for love and spontaneous generosity of a little child. Seita, the older boy, will move us through his genuine behaviour, his life-like gestures and the nature of his love for his little sister.


It's simple and it works, even in the horrid context of a world war. But it's also the authenticity of the depiction of love in those two kids that makes the violence of this movie nearly unbearable to endure. And it is the power of this movie to carve into our minds the mourning of two imaginary children....
Moving and horryfing at the same time but a also a stunning reminder of the magic of childhood. 10/10

LookingGlass
10
Écrit par

Cet utilisateur l'a également mis dans ses coups de cœur.

Créée

le 1 oct. 2015

Critique lue 812 fois

LookingGlass

Écrit par

Critique lue 812 fois

D'autres avis sur Le Tombeau des lucioles

Le Tombeau des lucioles
Silence
10

Les vestiges de l'absurde [9.7]

Il est parfois bon de filmer le comportement individuel de fourmis avant de filmer l'interieur de la fourmillière, puisque le tout ne signifie que la somme des particules... Isao l'a bien compris et...

le 31 mai 2013

138 j'aime

8

Le Tombeau des lucioles
Grard-Rocher
10

- "Le Tombeau des lucioles" dans mon "TOP 10" -

Durant l'été 1945, Seita, un adolescent de quatorze ans et sa petite sœur de quatre ans, Setsuko, bien qu'heureux auprès de leurs parents, vivent une enfance tourmentée dans un Japon secoué par la...

134 j'aime

56

Le Tombeau des lucioles
Hypérion
9

L'Enfance. Ravagée.

Je pouvais difficilement revoir Mon Voisin Totoro sans enchaîner sur son contemporain Le Tombeau des lucioles, piliers du succès du studio Ghibli. Comme pour Mon voisin Totoro, je pourrais me...

le 9 déc. 2011

124 j'aime

9

Du même critique

Les Arpenteurs du monde
LookingGlass
8

"Die Vermessung der Welt" von Daniel Kehlmann

I've just closed this excellent book and i must say i'm nearly tempted to start reading it again, it so exciting and pleasant to read. This novel offers us two apparently very distinct voyages : a...

le 18 oct. 2015

1 j'aime

3

La Main gauche de la nuit
LookingGlass
8

"The Left Hand of Darkness" by ursula Le Guin

My reading some Ursula Le Guin was long overdue. Now it's done and i'm very happy of that because she writes with amazing elegance. What a great book, this " Left Hand of Darkness" which tells us...

le 17 oct. 2015

1 j'aime

Tribulations d'un précaire
LookingGlass
9

A Working Stiff's Manifesto by Iain Levison

I've just finished this somewhat disenchanted autobiographical book about the human condition - if the human condition can be reduced to the strange life led by "poor workers", shifting between bad...

le 30 sept. 2015

1 j'aime